Last Job Standing®

Pick-up Artist at the Bar: The Comeback Kid?

Pick-up Artist at the Bar: The Comeback Kid?

We assess the comeback potential of bar pick-up artists and real-life romantic approaches as dating app fatigue peaks.

When Shallow Turns Deep

Okay, here we go. Our first article in the Fridays category. This is the category where we take deep dives or go shallow. The following article was intended to be in the shallow end, but ended up in the deep. The "occupation" in question is not really a career. It can be a pastime or a way to boost your ego for a brief moment, but it can also potentially get you the love of your life. What we are talking about is the pick-up artist at the bar.

For a long time, this "occupation" has been down and out. Eager Casanovas or Casanovettes (we are not sure if that's a word) have been having a field day, or rather a field decade, using the apps to hone their pick-up skills and get their validation and gratification needs fulfilled. In the comfort of their apartments, cars, bathrooms etc., they have been able to create the dream version of themselves.

Pretending to be successful and socially competent while hiding behind filtered pictures taken in a car, or from that one epic vacation that happened to be five years ago (time flies, but you kind of look the same, and if you eventually meet in real life, your date hopefully won't notice that you have gained a few pounds or lost some hair). Everything is allowed in love and war, right?

However, as people are getting tired of social media, dating apps, and addictive algorithms, they are increasingly looking to something different. The desperation in some people is so high that they are even switching from smart to "dumb" phones, where they can't download anything.

The Hero Enters: Real Life

The solution to get away from the web of the apps? No points for guessing; it's real life. Meeting people at cafes, at campus, at work, and yes, at bars.

However, there might be a slight problem: the bulk of an entire generation might have no clue how to do this. We're talking about people in their 20s and early 30s who have literally never approached someone without the safety net of a mutual "match" first. Their parents met at bars, concerts, and through friends. Their grandparents probably met at a dance. But them? Many have been swiping since they were 18.

There are also the single 40-50-60 year olds, who for the last decade have been turning on the apps, sometimes even before their partner has moved out. There is potentially some app exhaustion, and some real-life (re)training needed for this group as well.

Moving Away From The Shallow Swipe

This comeback isn't just about dating. People are not just learning to pick people up at bars; they're learning to exist in social spaces without a digital driver assist. You have to read body language instead of emoji reactions all by yourself, and you have to handle awkward silences instead of just unmatching.

The pick-up artist at the bar in 2025 isn't the sleazy guy with too much cologne and a repertoire of magic tricks. It's someone courageously attempting what past generations have been doing: talking to a stranger, in person, with romantic intent, without any algorithm to confirm mutual interest first. In this era, the main difference might be that women increasingly are the ones striking up conversations and trying out some new pick-up lines.

It might be terrifying. It might be time-consuming. You actually have to leave your living room to make something happen. It's probably going to lead to a lot of awkward encounters and bruised egos. However, these can be exciting times in the most authentic way possible.

THE PC Model Resistance Rating

Zero barriers. No license needed to talk to people at bars or anywhere else. Everyone can try, fail, learn, and try again.

After a decade of filtered profiles, many people are starving for the real thing. The real human part that seemed inefficient compared to apps is now the selling point. This factor is a major driver for the entire comeback.

More relevant than ever. You might get better insight into someone's actual values and judgments face-to-face and when meeting in a room full of other people. It can reveal the real character. Watching how they treat the bartender and react to the crowd.

For more than a decade we made courtship through apps, but now we have to figure out consent and boundaries in real-time, with real consequences. No moderators or report user functionality, just real-time ethics in action.

This comeback is all about physical presence. Being there. Showing up. No filters, no carefully chosen photos, just your actual self in an actual space. This is what makes it both terrifying and potentially increasingly appealing.

The app conversation templates might not work in real life. They're having to invent as they go, which makes every interaction a creative challenge.

Total Resistance Rating
4.0 / 5

Verdict: A Solid Comeback Potential

The high scores in Human Connection, Ethical Judgement, Physical Presence, and Creative Innovation aren't about resistance, they're about why this "occupation" as a pick-up artist can be roaring back from near extinction. These factors represent everything people are missing from digital dating.

If apps digitized romance, bars can be one of the places that rehumanize it. One bad pick-up line at a time.

Your Resistance Rating

How future-proof is this job?

You can give half stars

0 / 5

Average Reader Rating: 4.3/5 (6 votes)

Share on X Share on LinkedIn Copy Link